This Week in Sound: Where Acoustician Careers Go to Die

A lightly annotated clipping service

[](https://thisweekinsound.substack.com)

These sound-studies highlights of the week originally appeared in the October 11, 2022, issue of the free Disquiet.com weekly email newsletter This Week in Sound: [thisweekinsound.substack.com](https://thisweekinsound.substack.com).

ORCHESTRAL MANEUVERS: “Lincoln Center is where acoustician careers go to die.” That’s per Christopher Blair of Akustiks, the firm that led the acoustical engineering efforts on what is now Geffen Hall (formerly Avery Fisher Hall, when I was growing up on Long Island and would take school-chorus trips into Manhattan for the Messiah Sing-In each Christmas). Rivka Galchen, [in the New Yorker](https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/10/17/the-science-and-emotions-of-lincoln-centers-new-sound) this week, penned an even more detailed story about the renovation than the one mentioned last week. “I didn’t go to a rock concert until I was forty years old, and they paid me,” Blair tells the reporter. “That was Joan Jett. I told them to raise the speakers twelve degrees off of the floor if they wanted to stop receiving complaints from three miles away.

CHEW ON THIS: “Here we report a bite-controlled optoelectronic system that uses mechanoluminescence-powered distributed-optical-fibre sensors that are integrated into mouthguards,” [per the journal Nature](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41928-022-00841-8). In other words, you can bite to give instructions to a computer rather than type on a keyboard or speak aloud.

LET’S ROLL: There’s a widely shared story by Joanna Stern [in the Wall Street Journal](https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-owner-of-this-iphone-was-in-a-severe-car-crashor-just-on-a-roller-coaster-11665314944) that roller coasters are triggering the crash detection feature of the iPhone 14 and Apple Watch. And there is [some evidence](https://9to5mac.com/2022/10/09/roller-iphone-14-crash-detection-workaround/) that some of these incidents, at least at Dollywood, were actually caused when people tried to turn off their phones and accidentally dialed 911. (And I’ve written previously about other ways a phone can inadvertently trigger alerts.) (Thanks, Paolo Salvagione!)

LIFE IMITATES JOKE: A new Google Pixel phone “app listens to the hold music for you, then rings when it hears a human pick up.” Just one of several acoustics-oriented upgrades to the tech giant’s latest attempt to gain hardware market share, per [Fast Company](https://www.fastcompany.com/90793365/with-the-pixel-7-series-google-tries-again-to-answer-the-call-of-harried-phone-users).

GLOTTAL STOP: More on the use of fluid dynamics, [mentioned here recently](https://disquiet.com/2022/09/28/this-week-in-sound-audio-deepfakes-vs-basso-profondo-fakes/), to root out deepfake audios. As it turns out, [“deepfakes often model impossible or highly-unlikely anatomical arrangements.”](https://www.usenix.org/conference/usenixsecurity22/presentation/blue?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email) That is, researchers found that [“deepfaked audio samples simulated vocal tract shapes that do not exist in people.”](https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2022/10/detecting-deepfake-audio-by-modeling-the-human-acoustic-tract.html) (Thanks, Glenn Sogge!)

BROWN-IN: The Guardian’s [Emma Beddington](https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/oct/05/it-feels-like-fresh-air-to-my-ears-can-brown-noise-really-help-you-concentrate) of picks up the [currently growing](https://disquiet.com/2022/09/28/this-week-in-sound-audio-deepfakes-vs-basso-profondo-fakes/) story about the popularity of brown noise for people looking to improve their focus. Brown noise is sort of like white noise with the annoying higher-pitched end sheared off. [Author Zadie Smith is quoted: “I listen to brown noise … day and night. I live in this denuded soundscape.”](https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/oct/05/it-feels-like-fresh-air-to-my-ears-can-brown-noise-really-help-you-concentrate) (I used [a macOS app called Chill](https://apps.apple.com/us/app/chill/id421696351) for this — I find the “Airplane” setting particularly helpful, and have even listened to Airplane while on an airplane. On my iPhone, I use the “Dark Noise” setting in the [Background Sounds](https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/background-sounds-iphb2cfa052c/) feature.) It’s not for everyone. Beddington says her husband, who has tinnitus, “finds it aggravates rather than soothes his symptoms.” (Thanks, Christian Carrière!)

GLACIAL PACE: “Listening back to these field recordings now, I’m particularly struck by how cold the water sounds, as if I’d documented the water molecules’ audible shock of existence from solid to its newly liquified form.” Tristan Louth-Robins reports, [in his excellent blog](https://tristanlouthrobins.wordpress.com/2022/10/08/there-goes-the-ice/), about a group hike at Fox Glacier in New Zealand — and about revisiting such recordings much later: “Thinking back to these field recordings I made on Fox Glacier in 2010, I feel like they represent the temporality and morphology of place more than anything I’ve ever documented. Of course, you can’t hear this change, but its symbolism is there. Field recordings like this are delicate markers in time, before the ground shifts once again.”

CONSUMER RETORTS: On October 5, the makers of the Bitwig Studio suite of audio tools for musicians sent out an [email announcement](https://mailchi.mp/bitwig/new-bitwig-add-on-introducing-spectral-suite). They’d added a new piece of software, named Spectral Suite, at an introductory price of 79 (dollars or euros alike — either generously or onerously, depending on your local currency). By October 11, less than a week later, Bitwig had [changed course by 180 degrees](https://mailchi.mp/bitwig/spectral-suite-is-now-bitwig-studio-44). Spectral Suite would now be “part of Bitwig Studio,” the software having been updated to version 4.4 to accommodate the occasion. The language is important here, because in the initial announcement on October 5, Spectral Suite was described as “our first add-on product.” Language was at the heart of the issue due the pricing structure of Bitwig Studio. It’s a software subscription service, and “all” “updates” were expected by many users to be part of the fee — what’s an update and what’s ancillary was up for discussion. This new “add-on product” mode appeared to be something different. Except not different enough: The internet being the internet, musicians rallied, sometimes with a ferocity better suited to matters of actual life and death (the word “principle” can be a detrimental rhetorical device, drawing a line in the sand where there is, in fact, neither line nor sand). In the short term, Bigwig could have done a better job laying out its plans, and it has now acceded to the crowd’s demands. A lingering question is whether this “add-on product” model was an important part of the software’s — and the company’s — future business roadmap, and if so how Bitwig will adjust accordingly.

Subscribe to This Week in Sound: [thisweekinsound.substack.com](https://thisweekinsound.substack.com).

A Space Invader in Silvaplana

Doorbells of the world

Space invaders are welcome, clearly. Photographed in Silvaplana, Switzerland, by my friend Tobias Reber. Even beyond the arcade-ready symmetry, I love the inherent question resulting from the smudge at apartment 308. Did its tenants try — inappropriately by building standards — to personalize their button, and if so, what punishment was meted out? There’s also the question of the button retroactively designated as 100, which suggests itself as a building manager’s apartment. At some point someone apparently determined that it was as deserving of an identifying number as are the other apartments, even if the typography fails to match. What gave rise to this newfound egalitarianism?

Sound Ledger¹ (Bites, Datasets, Heartbeats)

Audio culture by the numbers

98%: Accuracy of using bite patterns to enter data

1,800: Number of audio files in a new large-scale dataset of emergency vehicle sirens and road noises for researchers

100,000: Number of recordings of user heartbeats already collected by a monitoring phone app

________
¹Footnotes

Bites: [nature.com](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41928-022-00841-8). Dataset: [nature.com](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41597-022-01727-2). Heartbeats: [newscientist.com](https://www.newscientist.com/article/2341665-smartphones-turned-into-electronic-stethoscopes-to-record-heartbeats/).

On Moving TWiS to Substack

An upgrade

As of October 11, 2022, my This Week in Sound email newsletter has moved to [thisweekinsound.substack.com](https://thisweekinsound.substack.com), including the full [archive](https://thisweekinsound.substack.com/archive).

Why the switch, why now, and why choose (after spending a heap of time looking at alternatives) Substack?

Interface: Tinyletter has a bunch of shortcomings, the overarching one being that it hasn’t appeared to have gotten much development attention in recent years. (This may be because a company bought Tinyletter in 2011, and then that company was bought by another company in 2021.)

Ceiling: Now that I’m sometimes sending out two issues of TWiS a week, I’ve gone well over Tinyletter’s limit. I literally couldn’t have sent an issue today, on schedule, if I’d stuck with Tinyletter.

Embeds: In Substack I can embed playable things like videos and audio right in the email. It’s like I’m suddenly in 2022. (SoundCloud playlists don’t seem to work, though, so maybe I’m still in 2020.)

Support: And, yeah, there are some payment options, which is nice, but the newsletter remains free. I may add something extra (key word: “extra”) for paying readers down the road, but have no specific plans at the moment. (Ideas appreciated, certainly. Thanks.)

Timing: Substack has scheduling built in. This means I can just set it to publish TWiS, which takes a lot of pressure off me.

As I mentioned yesterday, TWiS remains free, but of course feel free to get [a paid subscription](https://thisweekinsound.substack.com/subscribe) as a means to provide support. Thanks.

Moving ‘This Week in Sound’ to Substack

And some recommendations while I'm at it

The TWiS newsletter is being moved to Substack, at [thisweekinsound.substack.com](https://thisweekinsound.substack.com). If you were already a subscriber via Tinyletter, you shouldn’t need to resubscribe.

This is an experiment. I may end up using another system, but several friends of mine use Substack and it’s served them well — and I have experience with it as a reader, as I subscribe to a bunch of arts/technology/personal newsletters I enjoy. (I started my first email newsletter in 1994 as an editor for Towers Records’ magazine, *Pulse!*, and I know all too well that every service has its positives and negatives.) The TWiS newsletter remains free, but of course feel free to get a paid subscription as a means to provide support. Thanks.

Also, I had to come up with a logo to set the thing up, so the one up above is an initial pass. I’m fairly certain I’ll get something better together in time.

While I’m mostly interested in Substack for its publishing toolset, it does have other aspects to its infrastructure, a key one being its recommendation engine. In that spirit, here are some sound/music-related Substacks I recommend:

▰ Ethan Hein’s [Ethan Teaches You Music](https://ethanhein.substack.com) is an exceptional tool. He has a unique ability to apply a deep mastery of music theory to highly accessible music.

▰ [The World According to Sound](https://theworldaccordingtosound.substack.com/) is a about the potential of sound in various media

▰ Joshua Minsoo Kim edits [Tone Glow](https://toneglow.substack.com), which often features ecellent interviews with musicians toward the experimental end of the spectrum.

▰ Pavle Marinkovic’s [Sound Awareness](https://soundawareness.substack.com/) covers audio branding, music psychology, film scores, and more.

▰ [Shriek of the Week](https://shriekoftheweek.substack.com/) shares a different birdsong recording in each issue.

▰ Damon Krukowski’s [Dada Drummer Almanach](https://dadadrummer.substack.com) provides a musician’s-ear-view of music making and, especially, the business of music.

▰ Ted Gioia’s [The Honest Broker](https://tedgioia.substack.com/) is a great resource on a range of topics, especially classic jazz.

▰ [A Closer Listen](https://acloserlisten.substack.com) is another great music recommendation resource, very much aligned with Disquiet.com aesthetically.

▰ Matt Pinto’s [Caesura](https://caesuraletter.substack.com) is a quick shot of music recommendations.

If you have other suggestions for newsletters to follow (on Substack or otherwise), let me know. Thanks.